Mattheessen's

Mattheessen's is a famous dessert store in Key West specializing in ice-creams, cookies, fudges and lime pies. Every person, young or old who steps into the store eventually becomes a kid after browsing through their mouth-watering menu full of sugary goodness. If you're spoilt for choice and can't make up your mind, go for their chocolate chip cookies with pecans and macadamia nuts, rocky road fudge and toasted coconut ice cream which are some of their signature items.