Top Rated Restaurants & Cafes in Martha's Vineyard

This seasonal restaurant serves delicious American fare, with a twist of Italian and French. The very French name means to relax, release tensions and form good relations. That's exactly what patrons do here, in an attentive and casual ambiance. The staff is polite, efficient and knows when to leave you alone. Enjoy a meal with Island Lobster and Marrow Raviolis to start, followed by the Roasted Half Chicken and the tempting Warm Valrhona Chocolate Cake for dessert. A variety of dessert wines are available too. The extensive wine list features reds, whites, roses and sparkles, served by the half-bottle or the glass.

Sweet Life Cafe, located in the heart of Oak Bluffs is housed within a charming Victorian on the Circuit Avenue. The fine dining destination enjoys a wonderful location and features an elegant decor that lends a lovely, whimsical vibe to the place. There's a pretty patio arrangement that is just the right spot for a special date. And thanks to its intimate and upscale ambiance, Sweet Life Cafe also makes for a good option for special occasions. The cuisine served is just as refined and impressive as the rest of the place and includes fresh seasonal offerings cooked with high culinary standards and innovative techniques. Although the menu changes what remains constant is the scrumptious taste and sublime flavors of dishes such as seared scallops, braised pork cheek and lamb three ways, to name a few. There's a splendid, well-considered wine list available as well! All in all, Sweet Life Cafe makes for a stupendous treat!

Armed with healthy ingredients which are sourced locally, Alchemy prides itself on serving some of the most scrumptious food this side of the area! Presenting a collaboration of different flavors and tastes to arrive at the classic and delectable New American cuisine, the establishment has been earning several accolades for its eclectic menu which places a particular emphasis on local favorite seafood and meat dishes. Fried oysters are a recommended stalwart here, while other dishes are prepared with more flare. Think chicken liver crostini or yellowfish crudo. Have a romantic date on the outdoor porch, experience some of the area’s best fine dining, or head upstairs to the lively bar for an ingeniously concocted cocktail as you soak in the warmth of the fireplace!

This restaurant has been called "the most romantic restaurant on Martha's Vineyard" and many consider it the best, considering the ocean view enjoyed from every table. The menu, which changes daily during the peak season, features regional cuisine with an island twist, and guests can choose from a four-course prix fix or order a la carte. Beef Wellington has been a staple for 45 years, and there are always selections of locally caught seafood, often seasoned with herbs grown on the grounds. It also accommodates catered functions for up to 200 guests.

Acclaimed as one of the best dining establishments on the island, Lambert's features a rotating menu featuring such entrees as grilled honey orange duck breast served on a bed of caramelized onions with fruit chutney and sautéed Halibut Veronique with seedless green grapes, mushrooms, shallots, lemon and vermouth. For a great finish indulge in white chocolate cheesecake, banana foster crepes or Creme Brulee. Also on offer are a variety of wines, beer and delicious cocktails. The elegant dining room, in the Lambert's Cove Country Inn, has lots of windows, hardwood floors and a fireplace. It offers a relaxing and enjoyable way to spend an elegant evening.

Locally known as "Poppy", the Popponesset Inn Restaurant is a friendly dining spot in Mashpee that attracts locals and tourists who love its brilliantly cooked seafood preparations. Watch the waves lap the shore as you dine outdoors and sample the fine array of dishes laid on the table. catering orders are taken here. Private ceremonies and parties are also organized.